Season: 2025
| Name | Goals | Penalties | 
|  A. Drinan                                 (Swindon Town) | 10 | |
|  M. Cheek                                 (Bromley) | 7 | |
|  O. Patrick                                 (Tranmere) | 6 | |
|  A. Gilbey                                 (Milton Keynes Dons) | 6 | |
|  M. Dennis                                 (Notts County) | 6 | 1 | 
|  Kyreece Lisbie                                 (Colchester) | 5 | |
|  S. Duke-McKenna                                 (Harrogate Town) | 5 | |
|  H. Anderson                                 (Colchester) | 5 | |
|  A. Jatta                                 (Notts County) | 5 | |
|  N. Kabamba                                 (Bromley) | 5 | |
|  W. Davies                                 (Fleetwood Town) | 5 | |
|  C. Vernam                                 (Grimsby) | 5 | |
|  J. Kabia                                 (Grimsby) | 5 | 1 | 
|  D. Udoh                                 (Salford City) | 4 | |
|  C. Paterson                                 (Milton Keynes Dons) | 4 | |
|  C. Jennings                                 (Tranmere) | 4 | |
|  R. Graydon                                 (Fleetwood Town) | 4 | |
|  A. Dobra                                 (Chesterfield) | 4 | |
|  E. Khouri                                 (Grimsby) | 4 | |
|  A. Pressley                                 (Walsall) | 4 |